OCAD University Open Research Repository

System Error: Dance, Puppet Examining the structures behind the pressure to perform online, and imagining alternatives

Idam, Dania (2026) System Error: Dance, Puppet Examining the structures behind the pressure to perform online, and imagining alternatives. [MRP]

Item Type: MRP
Creators: Idam, Dania
Abstract:

Content culture — the everyday production, circulation, and consumption of digital media that defines contemporary online life — has become inseparable from the platforms that host it. What began as personal expression has hardened into a system in which visibility requires performance, attention is monetised, and opting out carries social and professional cost. This Major Research Project (MRP) examines how that system functions, what it does to the people inside it, and what alternatives are possible.

Using the Double Diamond framework, the research combines literature review, qualitative interviews, and netnographic observation of public discourse on X (formerly Twitter) to map contemporary content culture from the inside. Thematic, stakeholder, and Causal Layered Analyses, together with system mapping, reveal a set of reinforcing feedback loops between algorithms, advertisers, creators, and users that produce the fatigue, performance, and disconnection participants describe. The system is governed less by deliberate design than by the cumulative effect of incentives that make any individual's withdrawal costly.

Building on this analysis, the paper applies Dator's Four Generic Futures to project four scenarios for content culture in 2045 — Continued Growth, Collapse, Discipline, and Transformation — and selects Transformation as the preferred future: a "Commons" model in which content production is decoupled from advertising-attention metrics, and digital connection is governed by communities rather than platforms. Backcasting from this future, the paper outlines a three-phase pathway and a set of strategic interventions spanning regulation, platform architecture, and creator practice.

The contribution is less a forecast than a redirection; a way of seeing content culture not as inevitable, but as a system that was built, and can be remade.

Date: 2026
Uncontrolled Keywords: content culture; strategic foresight; performance imperative; algorithmic visibility; Causal Layered Analysis; backcasting; platform critique; creator economy; social media; generative AI
Divisions: Graduate Studies > Strategic Foresight and Innovation
Date Deposited: 07 May 2026 15:56
Last Modified: 07 May 2026 15:56
URI: https://openresearch.ocadu.ca/id/eprint/5093

Actions (login required)

Edit View Edit View