OCAD University Open Research Repository

A Systemic Co-Design Iceberg: A systemic perspective in the ever-evolving practice of empathic co-design

Smeenk, Wina (2022) A Systemic Co-Design Iceberg: A systemic perspective in the ever-evolving practice of empathic co-design. In: Proceedings of Relating Systems Thinking and Design, RSD11, 3-16 Oct 2022, Brighton, United Kingdom.

Smeenk_Re-Design_Paper_2022.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (691kB) | Preview
Official URL: https://rsdsymposium.org/


Societal challenges have become increasingly pressing. They affect us all: citizens, designers, and researchers. Truly understanding and tackling them is difficult because no single stakeholder nor organization is responsible for them, and everything is connected, interwoven, and in a current state of change. Moreover, there is mutual interaction and entanglements between people, non-humans, and technology. Next, systemic challenges based on the relationships, interactions, and experiences between stakeholders and their environments are dynamic. They evolve. Subsequently, it is hard to see the playing field. This makes challenges orphaned and stakeholders unable or unwilling to make all kinds of important decisions. This ambiguity leads to a lot of uncertainty. Combined with blind spots, implicit world views, tacit mechanisms, and latent values, this hinders change and limits social innovation capacity. Which raises the question: how to gain agency to individually act as a stakeholder in these complex challenges in a way that adds up to the collective?

Nowadays, design and, more specifically, systemic co-design are increasingly seen as possible approaches. Since design can deal with uncertainty, it is optimistic and inquisitive in nature. Moreover, supported by abduction logic, design makes creative leaps that can lead to radical change. Even more, a co-design and empathic approach allow for inclusivity by identifying and sharing stakeholders’ differences and interests, as well as shared perspectives and ambitions. This enables the creation of new bonds—potential new value networks—and co-imagining alternative futures. Yet, to make this empathic co-design potential work, the design profession must shift along with our transforming world. Design, therefore, needs to adopt new methodological and flexible strategies that support stakeholders in adaptively and empathically responding to dynamic contexts and collaborations. The main question arises: how to create a systemic co-design culture, approach, and structure that opens up stakeholders to reveal implicit world views, values, and mechanisms that will support their agency and provides for more inclusive, radical, and shared opportunities for change.

In this paper, I hypothesize that this requires working beyond methods that connect empathic co-design with a systemic perspective. I, therefore, contribute two new concepts. First, I introduce using explicit ‘sphere of life’ mechanisms as an ingredient in design abduction. Second, I argue that an ‘iceberg’ consisting of systemic co-design elements might give guidance to multi-stakeholder coalitions in identifying individual and collective latent values. Together they can lead to multi-value creation and systemic change in inclusive value networks.

Item Type: Conference/Workshop Item (Paper)
Uncontrolled Keywords: societal impact design, abduction, multi-value creation, systemic change, value networks, iceberg, spheres of life, (implicit) values, mechanisms
Divisions: Faculty of Design
Date Deposited: 04 Apr 2024 14:40
Last Modified: 04 Apr 2024 14:40
URI: https://openresearch.ocadu.ca/id/eprint/4261

Actions (login required)

Edit View Edit View